Before I start this off I wanted to clarify that I have not seen “The Last Airbender”, but that is mostly irrelevant to this article. But, seeing as it has 8% on RottenTomatoes.com I think I can at least say that I am pretty sure that this is another M. Night Shyamalan flop.
Watching M. Night Shyamalan’s decline has been like watching that guy in high school that everyone liked, and was voted “Most Likely to Succeed”, wind up being a registrar at a McDonald’s who gets drunk at the 10 year reunion trying to re-live the “good ol’ days’. He did two relatively unknown films, which apparently were in high regard among the indie community, before “The Sixth Sense”. In 1999 “The Sixth Sense” burst him onto the mainstream Hollywood scene with a killer twist of an ending and an outstanding performance by Haley Joel Osment. With his commercial success also came critical success, garnering three Oscar nominations for Best Picture, Best Director, and Best Original Screenplay. For a movie that was written and directed by the same guy, he was essentially nominated for the triple crown of the Oscars.
Then, came his next film, “Unbreakable”, reuniting him with Bruce Willis and bringing Princess Buttercup and Samuel L. Jackson along for the ride. While the film was not as much of a commercial success as Hollywood hoped, the technical style presented was exceptional and seemed like a very personal film for Shyamalan, bringing him critical acclaim for this one as well. Plus, with another decent twist ending he was hailed as someone who might be “Hollywood’s Next Hitchcock”. Thumbs up, Shyamalan! You’re doing pretty well so far as a young director.
Why yes, I get my hair done at the same place as Carrot Top and Nic Cage!
Enter “Signs”, a summer film that Shyamalan claimed to have written as a film for everyone, and for the most part it was. This film was a great commercial success, bringing in more than $225 million dollars domestically and all-in-all it was a pretty entertaining, albeit completely irrational movie. For the most part people forgave the irrational part of the movie and just enjoyed it, including critics who scored it 74% on RottenTomatoes.
But, it is here, with “Signs” that I first see the signs (haha, but seriously) of Shyamalan slowly starting to go off the deep end. I think a lot of it could be contributed to what seems like Shyamalan’s philosophy of quantity over quality, but it lacked some of the tightness and precision of his first two films. He had a good premise and translated it to the screen in an entertaining fashion, but to me it is in the dialogue that I find fault. The dialogue is very forced and seems too solemn and un-natural. Shyamalan seems to be on the opposite end of the spectrum from Quentin Tarantino when it comes to dialogue. Tarantino’s dialogue is very life-like, while Shyamalan is very rigid and does a lot more telling than showing. (Also, who says, “I’ll have a cheeseburger with bacon” when you can just say “bacon cheeseburger”?) Plus, we see his first trying-too-hard twist ending. Water? Really, dude? We are supposed to be surprised by this revelation, but a twist is supposed to be built up to and not contrived to be effective. It looks like he wrote the ending, then went back and tried to see how he could work things into the story to make it look like something surprising when it really wasn’t that shocking to begin with.
Coincidentally this film could have also caused the two main actors to both go legitimately insane.
Now, we come to “The Village” one of the biggest cinematic disappointments that I have seen in the theaters. While he sets up a pretty good premise for a suspense film, it is his dialogue again that torments me and actually gave away the “twist” ending to me in a way. Who talks like these people? Nobody, not even during the timeframe that it was supposedly set in. The dialogue is so unconvincing and bereft of emotion that it was painful to listen to. You can get all the technical aspects of a film right, the cinematography, the music, and the lighting (all of which he seems to do very well), but if you can’t deliver solid characters that people can support, understand, and relate to, then the film has no heart; it is just something nice to look at. While the dialogue isn’t as bad as say George Lucas’ in the new Star Wars movies, it is still just pretty awful.
The autobiographical story of how M. Night Shymalan grew up away from reality and normal people.
I am going to skip “Lady in the Water” because I have not seen all of it, but what I saw was just enough to let me know that Shyamalan was still heading in the wrong direction. Plus, he not only proved that his writing was souring, but that he couldn’t act either. At least in the films before “Lady” he only showed up on screen for a couple of minutes. In this one, he is a solid supporting character, which also earned him a Razzie for “Worst Supporting Actor.” In addition to that, he also received the Razzie for “Worst Director” for 2006. Tough break, buddy! But maybe you should just take a good 3-5 year break, collect your thoughts and maybe go watch some real people, instead of anime, to see what they are like to improve your writing style.
Instead of doing that, Shyamalan finally picked up on the hints from three movie studios that rejected his script “The Green Effect”, under the pretense that all of them said, “It needs a complete re-write and overhaul” and re-wrote it as the movie where trees kill people called “The Happening.” (One of the lamest titles I have ever seen which really didn’t give me much hope for the film itself). Suffice to say, while he still made a decent amount of money off of it, the film itself was far from a stellar rebound after “Lady in the Water.” Earning only 18% on RottenTomatoes, critics despised it and earned him even more Razzies. Plus, above all, he tainted Zooey Deschanel, one of the coolest actresses of today. I point primarily to the fact that the movie had no premise whatsoever (usually that’s a bad sign) and on top of that the dialogue again was awful. The characters’ decisions didn’t make sense, which isn’t uncommon in horror movies, but these were particularly bad. It’s definitely time to take a break right, M? I mean, 7 films in 10 years and each one getting worse and worse reviews? Salvage your reputation while people still admire you and take some time off to write another at least decent film…..
Or, come out with film #8….in 3D (I hate to say it M, but 3D doesn’t help bad dialogue). I promised I wouldn’t comment on that one any further because I haven’t seen it, so I will stop there.
Anyway, my point is that Shyamalan went wrong when he started pushing quantity over quality and sacrificing the heart that was seen in his first few movies. While he is a very technically gifted director and we all know he can write a decent film, he needs to be more particular about what he puts out and take the time and effort to put out another quality film, or even a mediocre one, to recover from the joke he is becoming in the world of film.
Tags: Chris Petersen, M. Night Shyamalan, movies, reviews, Signs, The Last Airbender, The Sixth Sense, The Village, Unbreakable